Update on Position / Glencoe Country Club
To the members of Glencoe Country Club and the greater Glencoe community:
It has not been a secret that I have had disagreements with the management of Glencoe Country Club (GCC) and dominant personalities within the Club. I am writing to provide an update on my position toward GCC.
In 2003, I published a review of the golf course at Epinions.com. In early 2004, this review caused a stir within the GCC community, particularly with its management, board of directors, and certain members. The review was received harshly because the arguments I made and the positions I took toward the course and the Club were unfavorable. I acknowledge that the review was primarily negative, citing a poor course design from the early 90s when it expanded to 18 holes from 9, the management style of the Club, and prevailing attitudes of some dominant personalities on the golf course.
The bottom line is that I have not played on this golf course since 2004 and I no longer have personal insight to the operations of the Club or experience playing on the golf course in nearly four years. As is the case, I no longer feel my review at Epinions is relevant, because it is dated and addresses problems that were realized leading up to 2003. For all I know, things have changed for the better. The course layout has not. Beyond that, I don't know how the Club is being managed, what it looks like (how the grounds are cared for), and don't know if the same negative experiences exist with certain members. As with any golf Club, there is turnover at GCC. I don't know the new members and am no longer familiar with the general culture and atmosphere of the Club/course.
Since that is the case, I took down my review of Glencoe Country Club from Epinions.com. Any other comments about GCC that I made publicly should be judged the same as those that were contained in the review at Epinions. If anybody wants a copy of the review, it is available upon request (it is archived).
Glencoe Country Club moved to ban me from playing on the golf course in either 2004 or 2005, in an official manner. I was informally banned from the club in early 2004. The reason cited for the ban was the Epinions review.
I appealed to the board in early 2006 to have the ban lifted, but the appeal was denied. I asked for certain conditions to be met at the Club and offered to take down the review at that time as part of a negotiated truce. This effort was rejected. As far as I know, the ban is still in effect.
My current position is one of indifference. Most of the people I used to regularly play golf with at the club are no longer members. I still do not appreciate the course layout and don't find it particularly enjoyable to play. I am a regular golfer and hold a dual membership at Shadowbrooke Golf Course and Whispering Pines golf course, both since 2004. In addition, I play many area golf courses and for that matter, courses around Minnesota and outside of the state.
I grew up and still reside in Helen Township, which is adjacent to Glencoe and enjoy many friendships and relationships with the wonderful people of the area - McLeod County. Naturally, I would like to at least have the option of playing at Glencoe Country Club, if only for convenience when somebody local calls and wants to play. It disheartens me to some extent that I have this negative relationship with an institution of the Glencoe community. But the intent of the review was to affect positive change, despite the interpretations of the Club management, board of directors, or members at the Club. It's your golf club; run it as you wish. You understand the consequences of poor management. You saw one of them in my review and public comments and you see it at the till when competing with area golf courses. I hope things have changed for the better. I hope that someday, somebody or a private firm acquires the Club and invests capital to reconfigure the golf course. Those are my wishes for GCC.
To conclude, I wish no further ill will toward GCC and offer the gesture of taking down the public review of the Club from Epinions. I imagine that someday I will again play on the course and I hope it will be a positive experience. Until then, best wishes to everybody involved with Glencoe Country Club.
Sincerely,
Brad Engelmann

